# A-015

- **Artifact ID:** A-015
- **Status:** RETIRED
- **Public record:** https://record.cybersecurityhq.com/assumptions#A-015
- **Machine-record SHA-256:** `d786e10e31716c90ce5e04a7c3d4567ff57c95e1faefa0485ea8741fbc121c68`

## Complete structured record

```json
{
  "id": "A-015",
  "statement": "Human-in-the-loop provides meaningful control over automated systems",
  "status": "RETIRED",
  "category": "Retired",
  "ledger_references": [],
  "retirement_date_bound": "On or before 2026-02-17",
  "retirement_rationale": "Historical retirement associated with CHQ-P-2026-005. The Position is REINFORCING and does not meet the ratified CONFIRMED threshold.",
  "supersession_pointer": "CHQ-P-2026-005",
  "related_positions": [
    "CHQ-P-2026-005"
  ],
  "retirement_evidence_state": "REINFORCING",
  "retirement_audit": "LEGACY — THRESHOLD NOT MET. Preserved as a historical state; not valid precedent for future retirement."
}
```